Welcome to Waterfront Mary's
Located at 3662 N Duluth Ave in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, Waterfront Mary's is a cherished dining destination known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere and stunning waterfront views. Guests rave about the delectable seafood offerings, particularly the light and flavorful perch, as well as the must-try chowder that has garnered high praise. The restaurant features both indoor and outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying a fish boil or the weekly "Fish Fry Friday." With attentive service and a dog-friendly environment, it's a place where fond memories are made and flavors delight. Waterfront Mary's embodies the essence of Door County dining, making it an unforgettable experience.
-
3662 N Duluth Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States3662 N Duluth Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States Hotline: +1 920-743-3690
Welcome to Waterfront Mary's, a dining gem nestled in the heart of Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. Located at 3662 N Duluth Ave, this charming restaurant offers not just a meal, but a complete sensory experience. With its stunning waterfront views, it’s an ideal stop after a hike at nearby Pot Park or simply a perfect spot to unwind with friends and family.
As I stepped inside, I was immediately enveloped by a warm and inviting atmosphere, enhanced by the friendly service that sets Waterfront Mary's apart. Customer reviews consistently praise the delightful offerings, from the light and flavorful perch to the celebrated seafood chowder, touted as the best around. The standout is their fish boil, an age-old tradition here. Guests recommend arriving a bit early to get settled, ensuring you don’t miss the spectacle of the boil's preparation.
One of the highlights of my visit was indulging in the Fish Fry Friday; the perch was available both deep-fried and pan-fried, with the latter being described by patrons as possibly the best they’ve ever tasted. This dish not only balanced a crispy exterior with moist, flaky fish but also boasted flavors so rich that they didn’t require the customary tartar sauce. I enjoyed the Cherry Mule, a vibrant cocktail that complemented the meal perfectly, adding a refreshing burst to my palate.
Outdoor seating is available, providing a lovely option for those who wish to bask in the natural beauty surrounding the waterfront. The restaurant is also dog-friendly, a feature highlighted by a delighted first-time visitor who had special accommodations made for their puppy. Such thoughtful service enhances the experience, making every diner feel welcomed.
With its diverse menu and friendly atmosphere, Waterfront Mary's is a must-visit for anyone in the area. Whether you’re a seafood lover or simply looking for a cozy place to dine, this charming establishment delivers delectable dishes and an unforgettable ambiance. Don’t miss the chance to experience the culinary delights of Waterfront Mary's — you’ll leave with a full stomach and a happy heart!
Great place to stop after taking a hike at Pot Park. Seafood Soup and chili both very good. Perch breading is nice and light with great flavor. I usually eat perch with tartar but this perch doesn't need it. (Tartar is good). Cherry mule was large and tasty.
The food here is really good, the prices are decent. There is indoor and outdoor seating. They have a fish boil here, but if you want to see it arrive about 20 minutes prior, it gives you time to park in the parking lot and get seated by the host. The boil we saw started about 5 minutes before it said it would be done.
Fish Fry Friday! Really good perch with fixins'. I had deep fried, wifee had the pan fried. Probably the best pan fried perch ever. Our server, Caesar was excellent. So blessed to have a real "Old Door County" place like this still around and apparently thriving. Also, the potato salad was at the highest level known to man.
This was my first time trying a fish boil, so I can’t compare it to others—but the overall experience here was absolutely amazing! From the warm and welcoming atmosphere to the fantastic service, everything exceeded expectations. And the best part? It’s dog-friendly! Michael even made a special fish boil dish just for my puppy, which completely made my day. The beautiful waterfront location is just the cherry on top. I can’t wait to come back!
This is a great place to eat! Everything is good but the chowder is the BEST. The location is odd but absolutely beautiful. Service was fantastic. They even have fish boils and old car shows. Give this restaurant a go, it's well worth it.
We had a great time at Waterfront Mary's during our stay in Sturgeon Bay. It was a short walk from our campground. We met Jeff the General Mgr, and he had great stories and a history of the establishment. He also gave us samples of their chowder and cod fish. It was so good we came back for the fish boil and it was outstanding. We also had their chowder, and it was so good we git bowls to go. Waterfront Mary's food is highly rated and a wonderful place to hang out.
Went 3 times! Great fried perch, Walleye. But the chest was the fish boil. Awesome to watch and delicious! And fabulous cherry pie at the end!
We stopped in for the traditional Friday night fish fry. The perch was really good. I also had a bowl of chili. It was thick with some decent flavor. Overall it was a fun place and laid back as it should be.